As a result of today's meeting what is agreed is actually to continue on the light reading group format with some small modifications:
1. We will have a reading group every two weeks
2. We will have a pool of papers to read and we will select one paper from that pool for every reading group. (To initiate this pool of papers, please write your paper suggestions as a comment to this post - send at least one paper suggestion until February 5)
3. Everybody will make their best to come to the reading group by reading the paper.
4. We will continue to the blog posts and google calendar entries for communication. You can setup your google calendar so that you receive reminders for every new entry.
So basically nothing has changed with respect to the last year except than the pool of papers. For me, last year's light reading groups were not that effective. If at one point we feel the same, then we will discuss again.
Another thing, at the meeting at some point it is said that "if nobody likes the paper the presenter will change it". I now think that maybe this is not a good idea. We should count on each others decision and read the paper anyway.
The ones who would like to have a heavy reading group will make a separate meeting.
Lastly, the first reading group will be on 12 February. Along with your paper suggestions please also say if you would like to be the first one.
oya